Frozen Butterbeer: The 10-Minute Blender Trick Every Harry Potter Fan Needs
Vanilla ice cream, cream soda, butter and a butterscotch drizzle turn into the frostiest frozen butterbeer, no wand required.
Dowell Cooks5 min readPrint this post
Four ingredients, one blender, zero wizarding degree required.
Hey, welcome back to Dowell Cooks! If you've ever wanted to feel like you just walked into a certain wizarding village on a cold afternoon, this is your recipe. It's a frozen butterbeer that comes together in one blender and about ten minutes, no wand, no potion class, no fancy equipment. Just vanilla ice cream, cream soda, butter and a good glug of butterscotch, blitzed into something that tastes like dessert wearing a drink costume.
Curious why this drink actually holds together instead of tasting like a random mashup? It comes down to one pairing doing all the work.
Vanilla Ice CreamButterscotch Syrup
Score 92Classic sundae topping.
Vanilla Ice CreamCream Soda
Score 85Classic float combination. Both carry creamy notes.
What to serve it with
This drink is rich enough to be dessert on its own, so I keep whatever's next to it simple. A basket of soft pretzels or some buttery popcorn gives you something salty to break up all that sweetness. If you're doing a whole movie-marathon spread, a plate of something savory like grilled cheese fingers or a cheese board balances it out nicely, since the butterbeer itself is all cream and sugar with almost nothing salty or sharp to cut it.
What to buy
Grab a good vanilla ice cream, something you'd actually eat by the spoonful, because it's doing most of the flavor work here. For the cream soda, any bottled version works, though the ones with real cane sugar tend to taste a little rounder. Softened butter matters more than people think: let it sit out so it blends in smooth instead of leaving little cold flecks. And don't skimp on the butterscotch sauce. It's the flavor that makes this taste like butterbeer instead of just a vanilla cream soda float.
Make it your own
Swap the cream soda for cola or ginger ale if that's what's in your fridge, both play well with the vanilla and butterscotch. Want it richer? Use clotted cream or mascarpone in place of the butter for an even more decadent finish. If you're after something lighter, cut the fat by using vanilla pudding mix instead of ice cream, it keeps the vanilla flavor but backs off the richness a bit for a version that's easier to sip more than once.
- Contains
- milk
- Fits
- Vegetarian, Pescatarian, Gluten-Free, Nut-Free, Halal, Kosher
Halal and kosher also depend on how the ingredients are sourced and certified.
Substitutions that still taste like the recipe.
Already covered swapping cream soda for cola or ginger ale, here's the fuller list if you want more options for every component.
- custard↓ fatty
- pudding↓ fatty
- vanilla pudding mix↓ fatty
- coconut water
Drier.
- cola
Brings clove-like and smoky notes; lacks the creamy and coconutty notes.
- ginger ale
Brings piney and citrusy notes; lacks the creamy and coconutty notes; more delicate.
- clotted cream
- cream
Lacks the fresh and grassy notes.
- ghee
Brings earthy and roasted notes; lacks the fresh and grassy notes.
- Dairy & Eggs
- $0.76
- Frozen Meals
- $1.00
- Beverages
- $8.78
- Baking
- $0.12
Common questions
Can I make this ahead of time?
Can I make it non-dairy?
Why does mine taste too sweet?
Is this actually keto or diabetic-friendly?
That's the whole recipe: one blender, four ingredients, and a treat that tastes like a movie night in a mug. Make it for a fan, make it for yourself, make it because it's hot outside and you want something cold and a little bit magical. Browse all recipes for more easy stuff like this, and go blend yourself a butterbeer.
The Quarterly
Get the next Quarterly from Dowell Cooks
Seasonal recipes, notes, and the issue links worth saving.
Comments